EU identifies serious defects in French GM rat study
EU identifies 'serious defects' in French GM rat study
In September a team from CRIIGEN at the University of Caen published the results of a two-year feeding trial of rats fed GM maize NK603 with and without Roundup, with Roundup alone and with controls on non-GM maize.
The study reported several disturbing results, including liver, kidney and pancreas harm, increased mortality and the increased and earlier development to tumours, especially in female rats.
But serious defects in the design and methodology of the paper mean it does not meet acceptable scientific standards and there is no need to re-examine previous safety evaluations of genetically modified maize NK603.
These are the conclusions of separate and independent assessments carried out by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and six EU Member States following publication of the paper in the journal Food and Chemical Toxicology on 19 September 2012.
The results of the French paper sparked a global debate about the safety of GM crops and Roundup, which focusses considerable attention on the validity of the experiments conducted by CRIIGEN.
CRIIGEN‘s research has been vigorously defended by the European Network of Scientists for Social and Environmental Responsibility (ENSSER), which points out that CRIIGEN used the same methods Monsanto used when applying for approval to import NK603 into the EU.
In response to Seralini's study, the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment, BfR, sprang to the defence of the herbicide Roundup.
BfR cited the industry tests on glyphosate, which it said showed the chemical does not cause carcinogenic effects.
These industry tests, and the German authorities' 1998 assessment of them, underpin the EU's current approval of glyphosate.
The new study is the first peer-reviewed research to analyze the validity of the regulatory approval of glyphosate.
The authors of the study have not seen the industry studies, which are kept secret under commercial confidentiality rules. However, they were able to examine the German authorities' report on them as a result of an access to information request to the German government.
While the new study confines itself to birth defects, the German authorities' report shows that the industry studies also indicated a carcinogenic effect from glyphosate. Germany dismissed this effect on the grounds that it does not follow a linear dose-response pattern: the effect does not increase in a straight line upwards as the dose increases.
EFSA today delivered its final evaluation of the paper by Séralini which raised concerns about the potential toxicity of genetically modified (GM) maize NK603 and of a herbicide containing glyphosate.
In particular, it suggested a link between exposure to these substances and an increased incidence of tumours in rats.
The Authority’s final review reaffirmed its initial assessment that the authors’ conclusions cannot be regarded as scientifically sound because of inadequacies in the design, reporting and analysis of the study as outlined in the paper.
Consequently, it is not possible to draw valid conclusions about the occurrence of tumours in the rats tested. Based on the information published by Séralini et al., EFSA finds there is no need to re-examine its previous safety evaluations of NK603 or to consider these findings in the ongoing assessment of glyphosate.
Per Bergman, who led EFSA’s work, said: “EFSA’s analysis has shown that deficiencies in the Séralini et al. paper mean it is of insufficient scientific quality for risk assessment.
In addition, several national organisations were independently mandated by Member States to assess this study. These reviews have demonstrated a consensus among a significant part of the EU risk assessment community that the conclusions of Séralini et al. are not supported by the data in the published paper. We believe the completion of this evaluation process has brought clarity to the issue.”
EFSA’s final statement considered the independent assessments of the paper by organisations of six EU Member States: Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Italy and the Netherlands. Full copies of these evaluations can be found in the annex of EFSA’s statement.
EFSA noted the emergence of a broad European consensus, with the reviewed Member State assessments finding the conclusions of Séralini et al. were not supported by the data presented in the study. Four of the national evaluations found the paper did not provide scientific information that would indicate the necessity to reopen the risk assessment of NK603 or glyphosate.
The exceptions were France’s High Council of Biotechnology and Italy, whose assessments did not examine this issue.
Member States also identified many of the same weaknesses in the methodology and design of the paper as raised by EFSA.
Unclear study objectives, the low number of rats used in each treatment group, a lack of detail on the feed and treatment formulation, key information missing on the statistical methods employed and incomplete endpoint reporting were all highlighted by Member State organisations.
Inadequate sample size
In the course of the review process, EFSA had requested Séralini et al. to provide further information on their study documentation. No such material had reached the Authority before publication of this statement.
However, on 9 November 2012, Séralini et al. published a general reply to the reactions from across the globe to their paper. After carefully examining the publication, EFSA concluded it provided only a limited amount of relevant information which failed to address the majority of the outstanding questions raised in the Authority’s first statement.
In their ‘Answer to critics’ document, Séralini et al. stated the sample size of their treatment groups was too small to allow them to draw conclusions with regard to long-term carcinogenicity and mortality.
EFSA noted this acknowledgement from the authors is inconsistent with the overall conclusions they made in the paper regarding the tumours and mortality.
EFSA’s evaluation of the Séralini et al. article was in keeping with its mission to review all relevant scientific literature for GMO risk assessment. The Authority remains committed to monitoring relevant literature on an ongoing basis to ensure the advice it provides is up to date.
Large scale progressive Shropshire arable business growing potatoes, combinable crops and maize with modern equipment require...
2,000 acre arable farm needs a sensible tractor driver to help with the harvest.You will be driving a tractor to carry out al...
We have a great opportunity for a self starting careful tractor driver who is able to organise their own time. The role invol...
We are seeking to employ a casual worker for the summer period to help across the estate and horse trials areas of the busine...
Keen energetic person required to assist on a mixed family farm with hay making, harvesting, autumn cultivation and...
Farming UK | Farms and Land
Barbers Rural (13)
Barlow Associates (2)
Batcheller Monkhouse - Haywards Heath (1)
Berrys - Kettering (1)
Bidwells - Perth (1)
Brown & Co - Bury (3)
Brown & Co - King's Lynn (1)
Brown & Co - Norwich (2)
Bruton Knowles (2)
BTF Partnership LLP (1)
Carter Jonas - Bath (5)
Carter Jonas - Cambridge (1)
Carter Jonas - Harrogate (5)
Carter Jonas - Kendal (2)
Carter Jonas - Newbury (2)
Carter Jonas - North Wales (1)
Carter Jonas - Oxford (5)
Carter Jonas - Shrewsbury (1)
Carter Jonas - Wells (2)
Carter Jonas - Winchester (1)
Carter Jonas - York (2)
Charnock Bates (1)
Cheffins - Ely (1)
Churchill Country & Equestrian Estate Agents (2)
CKD Galbraith - Aberdeen (1)
CKD Galbraith - Ayr (1)
CKD Galbraith - Castle Douglas (3)
CKD Galbraith - Edinburgh (3)
CKD Galbraith - Galashiels (1)
CKD Galbraith - Inverness (1)
CKD Galbraith - Kelso (1)
CKD Galbraith - Perth (2)
CKD Galbraith - Stirling (10)
Cooper & Tanner LLP (1)
Corum Property (1)
Cruso & Wilkin (1)
Cundalls - Malton (1)
Cundalls - Pickering (2)
David James and Partners - Old Sodbury (1)
David Parry & Co (2)
Dee Atkinson & Harrison - Beverley (1)
Dee Atkinson & Harrison - Driffield (1)
Donald Ross (3)
Edward H Perkins (1)
Edwin Thompson - Berwick upon Tweed (1)
Edwin Thompson - Galashiels (1)
Elstons, Country Land & Estate Agents (2)
enfields - Pontefract (1)
Express Estate Agency (1)
Fine & Country Homes from Mortimers (2)
Fisher German - Ashby de La Zouch (8)
Fisher German - Banbury (1)
Fisher German - Knutsford (1)
Fisher German - Retford (1)
Fisher German - Stafford (2)
Fisher German - Thame (1)
Fisher German Denton Clark - Chester (1)
Fisher German John Sanders - Bromsgrove (1)
Fisher German John Sanders - Worcester (1)
Foster Maddison - Hexham (1)
Foster Maddison - Lanchester (1)
Fox Bennett (1)
Fox Grant - Salisbury (9)
Fox Grant - Sherborne (3)
Fox Grant - Taunton (4)
G. Herbert Banks (2)
Gary Hoerty Associates (1)
George F White - Alnwick (1)
George F White - Wolsingham (1)
Grange Solicitors and Estate Agents (1)
Greenslade Taylor Hunt - Bridgwater (1)
Greenslade Taylor Hunt - Burnham-On-Sea (1)
Greenslade Taylor Hunt - Taunton (1)
Greenslade Taylor Hunt - Tiverton (1)
H&H Land and Property - Carlisle (2)
Hamnett Hayward - Aylesbury Vale and Chilterns (1)
Hamnett Hayward - Thame (1)
Hamptons International - Banbury (1)
Hamptons International - Bath (1)
Hamptons International - Broadway (1)
Hamptons International - Buckingham (1)
Hamptons International - Caterham (1)
Hamptons International - Cirencester (1)
Hamptons International - Deddington (1)
Hamptons International - Epsom (1)
Herbert R Thomas - Cowbridge (1)
Herbert R Thomas - Neath (1)
Hinson Parry & Co - Newcastle-under-Lyme (1)
Hopkinsons Estate Agents (1)
Humberts - Chippenham (1)
Humberts - Marlborough (1)
Humberts - Taunton (1)
J.J. Morris - Cardigan (1)
Lambert and Foster - Cranbrook (1)
Leonards - Hull (1)
Mansell McTaggart - Copthorne (1)
Mansell McTaggart - Crowborough (3)
Mansell McTaggart - Forest Row (4)
Mansell McTaggart - Hassocks (1)
Mansell McTaggart - Haywards Heath (1)
Mansell McTaggart - Uckfield (2)
Maxey Grounds & Co - Wisbech (1)
McCartneys - Brecon (1)
McCartneys - Craven Arms (1)
McCartneys - Hay-On-Wye (1)
Michael C L Hodgson - Grange-over-Sands (1)
Michael C L Hodgson - Kendal (1)
Michael Graham - Aylesbury (1)
Michael Graham - Buckingham (1)
Michael Graham - Northampton (1)
Michael Graham - Princes Risborough (2)
Morris Marshall & Poole - Newtown (1)
Morris Marshall & Poole - Shrewsbury (1)
Pelhams Equestrian Rural & Land Agents (1)
Perkins George Mawer & Co (1)
Pike Smith and Kemp Rural - Maidenhead (1)
Pike Smith and Kemp Rural - Marlow (1)
Robert Bell and Company - Lincoln (2)
Robert Bell and Company - Woodhall Spa (1)
Rural and Equestrian Ltd (2)
Rural Scene (1)
Savills - Cambridge (1)
Savills - Edinburgh (1)
Savills - Exeter (2)
Savills - Jersey (1)
Savills - London Head Office (2)
Savills - Norwich (1)
Savills - Nottingham (1)
Savills - Telford (1)
Savills - York (1)
Seddons - Bampton (1)
Seddons - Honiton (1)
Seddons - Tiverton (1)
Smiths Gore - Dumfries (2)
Smiths Gore - Edinburgh (1)
Smiths Gore - Oxford (2)
Smiths Gore - Taunton (2)
Smiths Gore - York (2)
Smiths Surveyors (1)
Stags - Bideford (1)
Stags - Farm Agency (4)
Stags - Honiton (2)
Stags - Tiverton (1)
Stewart & Watson - Huntly (1)
Strutt & Parker - Banchory (1)
Strutt & Parker - Canterbury (1)
Strutt & Parker - Chelmsford (2)
Strutt & Parker - Chester (1)
Strutt & Parker - Edinburgh (2)
Strutt & Parker - Exeter (4)
Strutt & Parker - Inverness (2)
Strutt & Parker - Morpeth (1)
Wallets Rural Property Services (13)
Williamson and Henry (1)
Willsons Chartered Surveyors - Alford (1)
Woodlands - Northern England (1)
Wright Manley - Crewe (1)
Wright Marshall - Buxton (1)
Wright Marshall - Chester (1)
Wright Marshall - Crewe (1)
Wright Marshall - Nantwich (2)
Wright Marshall - Northwich (9)
Wright Marshall - Tarporley (2)
Wright Marshall - Whitchurch (1)
Youngs RPS - Hexham (1)
Argyll and Bute (2)
Channel Islands (1)
County Durham (1)
Dumfries & Galloway (17)
East Sussex (5)
East Yorkshire (2)
North Yorkshire (8)
Perth and Kinross (2)
Scottish Borders (7)
South Yorkshire (1)
West Midlands (2)
West Sussex (3)
West Yorkshire (4)
Farming UK Holiday Rentals
Argyll and Bute (1)
County Durham (24)
Dumfries & Galloway (7)
East Lothian (4)
East Sussex (5)
East Yorkshire (9)
Isle of Anglesey (2)
Isle of Wight (3)
North Yorkshire (97)
Outer Hebrides (1)
Perth and Kinross (3)
Scottish Borders (8)
South Yorkshire (1)
Tyne & Wear (1)
West Lothian (8)
West Midlands (1)
West Sussex (4)
West Yorkshire (5)
A strong pound and increased red meat imports coupled with a plentiful dome...
Depression is affecting Wales' farming industry and there is a need to use ...
With just one week to go before the final judging and announcement of the w...
A rural law expert has highlighted the importance of good succession planni...
A south Yorkshire dairy farming family is pulling out all the stops to prom...
Predicting what is going to happen to wheat prices is a challenge, but in s...
A Lancashire based livestock theft prevention scheme is aiming to go nation...
A female farmer has been recognised by the farming and conservation industr...
The new Conservative government appears to be preparing to implement cuts f...