30 June 2015 | Online since 2003

Green farm subsidies unworkable rural lawyer

2 February 2012 16:16:58|Grassland,Property News,News,Renewables

Green farm subsidies 'unworkable' - rural lawyer

A rural legal expert has criticised ’seriously flawed’ EU proposals to dramatically alter farm subsidies which she says could significantly change the UK’s farming landscape.

The comments come from agricultural lawyer Sarah Baugh following recent speeches from the Environment Secretary Caroline Spelman and the country’s leading rural policy advisors. Ms Baugh has questioned the new Brussels-led scheme which she calls ’vastly bureaucratic’ and one that could complicate agricultural payments.

The new Direct Payments Scheme, proposed by the EU to begin in May 2014, seeks to make farmers work harder to qualify for European subsidies. Under the proposals, farmers will be forced to be far more environmentally friendly, qualify under strict new rules and agree to a number of other provisions.

Ms Baugh, a partner at Midland legal firm MFG Solicitors, commented: "The debate surrounding the new farming subsidy proposals is gathering pace but the details are making the farming community extremely nervous.

"The new system allows subsidy applications from only ’active farmers’ to whom the direct payments must represent at least five per cent of their receipts from non-agricultural income. However, that policy oddly risks excluding many farmers whom, although actively farming in any usual sense, have diversified into other businesses just to keep their heads above water.

"The vastly bureaucratic proposals also attempt to change the agricultural landscape through a compulsory ’greening’ provision. In short, this will mean to qualify for subsidy payments, any farmer with over three hectares of land not entirely used for grass, will be forced to a plant a minimum of three types of crop.

"Whilst that provision might tick the political box in terms of increased food production, it seems to give no thought to livestock farmers who naturally require an arable area to produce feed for their cattle but will certainly not wish for three unwanted crops to be imposed on them."

Ms Baugh continued: "Farmers are equally baffled to learn that only farm businesses who applied for subsidies in spring 2011 will be eligible under the new scheme.

"That leaves new entrants and young, future farmers exposed, partnerships which break up with potentially explosive decisions on who takes the single ’golden ticket’ and restricts the market for farmers wanting to retire and sell their land with the benefit of subsidies. That oversight seems to be down to a lack of understanding of basic farming practice and how farming transactions work." said Ms Baugh.

Earlier this month, Environment Secretary Caroline Spelman said future farming subsidies should be focussed on ’public good’ and the ’landscape’, in addition to a basic rate of support.

Ms Baugh, a nationally respected commentator on legal farming matters, added: "I back Mrs Spelman’s calls to encourage more sustainable farming practices and accept that there have to be some rules imposed as to how applicants qualify. But as they stand the proposals are seriously flawed, unworkable and have complicated an already complex process whilst claiming to be a ’simplification’.

"The Brussels law makers have left too many stones unturned. That lack of detail has left thousands of this country’s farmers anxious about a framework which promised so much but looks like delivering something very different."

Every year in the UK over £2 billion in subsidies is distributed to farmers.



No comments posted yet. Be the first to post a comment

To post comment without approval login or register

Display name

Please enter your name

Email (optional)

Please enter your comment

Post Comment

Your comment submitted successfully.Please wait for admin approval.

Some error on your process.Please try one more time.


Start Date: 18 June 2015
Herds Person for job on dairy farm in North Shropshire, near Shrewsbury

To work as part of a team, 300 cow herd.

New facilities - new parlour, sand cubicles and lagoon. Excellent working enviro...

Start Date: 29 June 2015
A427: Territory Sales Person - Agricultural Machinery - West Midlands

De Lacy Executive seek an experienced and enthusiastic sales person with drive and determination, to cover a sales territory ...

Start Date: 28 June 2015
Love Pigs? Job in Cambridgeshire for a pig man 3,000 indoor pigs.

3,000 indoor pigs need to be looked after. You will be involved in all areas of the farm but your main task will be looking a...

Start Date: 26 June 2015
Harvest Work Job for 3 people >>>Oxford<<<

3 people required for harvest on 2000 acre farm with red deer herd. One to run grain store (training will be given) and ...

Start Date: 29 June 2015
S140: Agricultural Office Manager - York

De Lacy has been engaged to recruit an Office Manager for a national agricultural business for a new office in York. The indi...

Top stories you may have missed
5 June 2015 | Cattle

A strong pound and increased red meat imports coupled with a plentiful dome...

5 June 2015 | Arable

Depression is affecting Wales' farming industry and there is a need to use ...

5 June 2015 | Arable

With just one week to go before the final judging and announcement of the w...

5 June 2015 | Finance

A rural law expert has highlighted the importance of good succession planni...

5 June 2015 | Farmshops

A south Yorkshire dairy farming family is pulling out all the stops to prom...

4 June 2015 | Finance

Predicting what is going to happen to wheat prices is a challenge, but in s...

4 June 2015 | Agri Safety

A Lancashire based livestock theft prevention scheme is aiming to go nation...

4 June 2015 | News

A female farmer has been recognised by the farming and conservation industr...

4 June 2015 | Finance

The new Conservative government appears to be preparing to implement cuts f...

4 June 2015 | Arable

The Rural Payments Agency (RPA) will have mobile support units at the follo...