26 April 2015 | Online since 2003

Mass cull 'not the answer' says deer group

The call for a nationwide cull of half the UK's deer population following the publication of a report by the University of East Anglia has been branded as 'extreme' by the Association of Deer Management Groups.

The University report claims that culling deer at this level would stop damage to woodland structure and vegetation.

"A mass UK wide cull is not the answer" said Richard Cooke, Chairman of both the Association of Deer Management Groups and the Lowland Deer Network Scotland.

"This should not be about numbers, but about impacts, and in Scotland I would argue strongly that we know what our responsibilities are, we know where deer species are impacting locally, and we know how to tackle that."

The association said the report's conclusions 'should not be presumed to apply in Scotland' where the deer related problems are the exception and not the rule.

The total population stands at around 1.5 million and a study released by the Journal of Wildlife Management said numbers would be more stable if a cull was allowed to commence.

The Wildlife and Natural Environment Bill Scotland has helped to reinforce the duties of deer managers to manage the deer on their ground sustainably.

Research has shown there are now more deer in the UK than any time since the Ice Age and the RSPCA said a cull must first be based on strong science.

The RSPCA said they were "opposed in principle to the killing or taking of all wild animals unless there is strong science to support it, or evidence that alternatives are not appropriate.

"Even if a cull is supported by science, it is very important that it is carried out in a humane and controlled way.

"Any decision to carry out a cull must be taken on a case by case basis based on the specific issues which impact a specific area. We don't believe this should be rolled out in a uniform way across the whole country. It is certainly not a case of one size fits all."

Although population numbers of roe deer in Scotland's low grounds are less precise, both public and private sector interests are involved and the new Lowland Deer Network Scotland has been established to bring together all relevant bodies including farmers, landowners and local authorities.

The Scottish Gamekeepers Association has also said a culling would 'spell disaster' for many rural communities.

Gamekeepers believe, if this was carried through in Scotland, it could make many communities in rural Scotland unviable, leading to job losses.

Scottish Gamekeepers Association Chairman Alex Hogg said: "It would be absolutely and unequivocally wrong to take this science, gleaned from studying one forested area of East Anglia, and apply it to all parts of the UK, particularly Scotland. A one-size-fits-all approach would have serious repercussions."

In Scotland, some areas have a deer population which requires careful, selective management to keep the numbers balanced at the right level.

However, in other areas the affects are being felt because deer have virtually vanished, largely due to unfenced forest regeneration.

In many of these areas, stalking income keeps the hotels and guest houses, shops and schools open. It keeps jobs in these areas and the benefits trickle down through the community. Many of these communities are struggling because deer numbers have fallen so low.

"Culling at the levels suggested, therefore, from a figure plucked from one area of East Anglia, could lead to empty glens if sustained.

"Conservation would work better, and would be better applied, if it also took people into account."



08-03-2013 12:24 PM | Posted by: p munro
Why not employ people to monitor there numbers and try some kind of contreception,killing any wild animal is not the answer,it's there natural habitat which we are invading,it's such a pleasure driving along the country side and seeing those lovely creatures.

08-03-2013 12:35 PM | Posted by: Hungry Brit
If Deer have become a problem then use the volume to solve other issues.
Why not put a government scheme in to bring Dear at a low cost even the poor can afford to our dinner tables?
Would that idea be too crazy? I’m sure using the meet to help the poor will be a benefit to everyone!!

08-03-2013 12:42 PM | Posted by: Laura
A good start would be to start to eradicate the non-native chinese water deer, muntjac deer and sika deer then see how the woodland recovers before culling native species like the red deer and the roe deer.

08-03-2013 13:01 PM | Posted by: the Doc
there is no scientific reasoning for a cull. All species of deer are rare enough in England for them to be protected, there is no sustainable breeding population, in that the genetic diversity is already suffering from low numbers. The problem is people. There is not enough land that is not being developed, there are no corridors for separated populations to be reunited through, creating tiny pockets with extremely shallow gene pools.

08-03-2013 13:24 PM | Posted by: Luddite
Could the deer from overpopulated areas not just be moved to the areas where the deer population has dipped?

08-03-2013 14:24 PM | Posted by: REALITY SUCKS
look what if we kill 'em and eat them before plague and disease do cuz then they ain't good to eat

08-03-2013 15:00 PM | Posted by: Lou.
I dont agree with the cull specailly when evidience is based one study of an area. I would want to see the report/ study which may raise more questions. This area may have more human population than others thus depleating the territory of the deer. What type of deer are in this area vs human? Whats the human growth of this area and impact it has on other species? What is the food source? I would want solid proof or ground evidience that such a deed would deem necessary. Nature has its way of evening itself out to create the balance it needs.

08-03-2013 15:10 PM | Posted by: Cull on Humanity
Why not use this logic on humanity? We destroy the environment and just won't stop breeding. A cull of the human population should be just as plausible as toward any other species.

08-03-2013 15:30 PM | Posted by: Handsome
Part of the argument was that X amount of trafic accidents caused by deer were affecting and killing X amount of drivers. Answer: Drivers should look at and heed the warning signs indicating deer, drive slower and be more aware.

This would also kill less deer.

To post comment without approval login or register

Display name

Please enter your name

Email (optional)

Please enter your comment

Post Comment

Your comment submitted successfully.Please wait for admin approval.

Some error on your process.Please try one more time.


17 April 2015
Service Controller (Plant)
Service Supervisor, Plant, HGV, Construction, agriculture, depot, engineer, progression, training, hire, NVQ, HND, HNC, fleet...

24 April 2015
Harvest Students Herts/Essex Border
Accommodation will be in mobile homes on one of the farms; Our client with 4,000 acres of combinable crops around Bishop's St...

7 April 2015
Major Gifts Coordinator
You’ll also have dairy management experience, strong people and communications skills and the ability to build good working r...

17 April 2015
Farm Secretary
PART TIME FARM SECRETARY. Required for diverse farming / commercial / residential lettings business in Matching area....

9 April 2015
Countryside Maintenance Assistant - Parks and Countryside
Sandwell Park Farm, Sandwell Valley Country Park, Salters Lane, West Bromwich B71 4BG. Fixed term until 7 September 2015 to c...

Top stories you may have missed
10 April 2015 | Agri Safety

The permanent eradication of Bovine Viral Diarrhoea [BVD] in Scottish cattl...

10 April 2015 | Dairy

The abolition of milk quotas in Europe on 1st April has resulted in a numbe...

10 April 2015 | Cattle

The top 14 milk producing countries in Europe will increase their productio...

10 April 2015 | News

Matt Ware is the NFU's head of government and parliamentary affairs, based ...

10 April 2015 | Arable

There is a 'desperate need' to improve farmgate returns given low incomes a...

9 April 2015 | Arable

Rapid stem extension, after a slow start to spring, is likely to create spl...

9 April 2015 | Finance

The time has come for landlords to expect to see reductions in farm rents, ...

8 April 2015 | Cattle

Cogent’s reputation as a source of the highest calibre sires has been enhan...

8 April 2015 | Arable

The spread of exotic and aggressive strains of a plant fungus is presenting...

7 April 2015 | Animal Health

The FSA’s new Food Crime Unit wants the industry to share information, some...