26 January 2015 | Online since 2003



RSPCA accused of bullying after badger cull threats


The NFU has accused the RSPCA of hypocrisy after farmers were warned they could lose their valued Freedom Foods status if they supported or allowed badger controls on their land.

In a letter to scheme members, Freedom Food, a wholly owned subsidiary of the RSPCA, claims that, ‘based on the current science, welfare concerns and a realistic assessment of what is practical, a widespread cull of badgers is totally unacceptable to the RSPCA’.

It goes on to say that under the standards, Freedom Food members are required to apply ‘all reasonable non-lethal and humane methods of wild animal exclusion/control’.

Freedom Food adds that it believes it is ‘unacceptable to use lethal methods of wild animal control as routine practice’.

The letter states: “As such Freedom Food would regard it as unacceptable for any of its members to voluntarily take part in a badger cull for the above reasons. To do so would also bring the scheme into disrepute and be a clear breach of the membership agreement, resulting in suspension.”

"The NFU takes this threat to its members very seriously" said NFU Director of Policy Martin Haworth.

"Our lawyers are currently looking at this in detail, but have yet to identify the wording used in this letter in the actual Freedom Food standards. In fact, the RSPCA’s welfare standards for beef cattle, for example, state that farmers must manage the levels of potentially harmful pests to avoid the risk of disease spread, and that while methods of physical exclusion must be included whenever possible, if such methods are inadequate or unsuccessful, other approaches must be enacted.

“I note that the RSPCA says it is “unacceptable to use lethal methods of wild animal control as routine practice”. To connect this to the government’s TB eradication programme is a nonsense. The planned badger controls are only one part of a wider package of measures to tackle bovine TB."

"In no way is it “routine”. The pilot areas have been specifically licensed by Natural England, under the Protection of Badgers Act for the absolute purpose of preventing the spread of disease. The cull will be confined to defined areas and will be heavily regulated. It will also be strictly monitored by an independent group to confirm it is safe, it’s humane and effective in controlling this terrible disease.

“Questions should be asked of the RSPCA’s objectives. It fully supports culling as a routine practice for deer, for example, with 350,000 removed annually. The same goes for rats and rabbits. Have Freedom Food members ever been suspended on these grounds? In this light, we can’t help but see the Freedom Food letter on badger culling as hypocritical.

“I feel extremely disappointed that the RPSCA has resorted to such tactics normally reserved for other animal rights organisations. It seems to us that this letter has nothing to do with the welfare of farm animals, which is what the Freedom Food scheme is all about. Instead, it looks to us like the RSPCA trying to attack farmers’ businesses financially to try to stop farmers from lawfully participating in what is a sadly necessary step to tackle a devastating animal disease, just as the RSPCA has tried to do by calling on shoppers to boycott milk produced on dairy farms in the cull areas.”

Download



Comments


15-10-2012 09:27 AM | Posted by: Penny
Nice one RSPCA, no one supports this cull, and it would be wrong for products to carry the Freedom Foods Standard if badger culling is involved!

15-10-2012 09:40 AM | Posted by: animalnut
Since the Freedom Food scheme is little more than a protection racket, it wouldn't be much of a loss. Since when did a charity with no legal powers powers dictate terms to farmers, governments etc.? The RSPCA are way above themselves. Given that they themselves slaughter more than 60,000 animals per year, they are hardly in a position to dictate to others.!

15-10-2012 09:42 AM | Posted by: Clued-Up
Attacks on the RSPCA (an organisation the public largely respects) by the NFU (regarded as the special interests party of farmers)reduce any sympathy the public may have for the farming community.

The RSPCA are regarded as the experts in preventing animal cruelty and rescuing animals from human cruelty. When they - and other wildlife organisations - say the badger cull will result in huge suffering as wounded badgers drag themselves off to die, they'll be believed.

The badger cull is incredibly unpopular with the public. They know the UK's best scientists say the cull won't reduce cattle bTB and may even increase it. They know tighter control of cattle is already leading to a 30% reduction in bTB over the six months it's been tried. They also know a new cattle vaccine (capable of ending the scourge of bTB)has already been developed and could be available within months if the political will backs it.

It would be in the best interests of farmers if the NFU started to build bridges again with the public. The organisation should stop talking about and working for killing badgers. It should begin talking to government about how to improve farm incomes and the scope for taxpayer support to meet the extra costs of phasing in the new bTB vaccine.

16-10-2012 16:12 PM | Posted by: Protectbadger
When it's in a messy hole created by itself, the NFU should stop digging, making its reputation even worse

The statements made by the RSPCA sound fine.
It would be inconsistent for the Freedom Food label to be associated with a cull of badgers.

08-02-2013 09:24 AM | Posted by: Doglistener
The RSPCA are not winning any plaudits recently from killing German shepherds with a Bolt gun to neutering pups at six weeks old.

They have been highjacked by ALF and are more a political party than a charity. I believe they shoul;d lose their status as a charity and lose their Royal warrant.

To post comment without approval login or register

Display name

Please enter your name

Email (optional)
Comment

Please enter your comment

Post Comment

Your comment submitted successfully.Please wait for admin approval.

Some error on your process.Please try one more time.



Jobs


13 January 2015
Weekend Poultry Worker Howey (Guafron)
General farm duties such as ground maintainence including use of equipment. >...

7 January 2015
Quantity Surveyor - Durham
Due to on-going success and contract awards they have a requirement for a Quantity Surveyor to join their Durham office to wo...

16 January 2015
VEHICLE PREPARATION AGENT
Park Farm Industrial Estate. We are looking for a smart, bright and hardworking individual to join our company based in Welli...

22 January 2015
Warehouse & Rework Team Leader
Warehouse and Repack Team Leader Things move fast here, especially in and out of our warehouse and repack facility. If you ha...

20 January 2015
Service Desk / Help Desk Analyst
Windows Server 2012 migration, Exchange 2010, CRM 2011 and SQL 2012 including clustering and web farm load balancing hosted o...




Top stories you may have missed
12 November 2014 | Arable
GM crops 'good for farmers and the envir...

GM crops 'good for farmers and the envir...

GM crops are good for the economy and can reduce the amount of pesticides u...


6 November 2014 | Cattle
Smaller European markets drive beef expo...

Smaller European markets drive beef expo...

Demand from smaller European markets has helped drive strong growth for UK ...


6 November 2014 | Agri Safety
Lack of engineers a 'ticking time bomb' ...

Lack of engineers a 'ticking time bomb' ...

A lack of engineers, not enough people promoting the land-based industries ...


4 November 2014 | Bees and Beekeeping
Bee action plan due: Last chance for bee...

Bee action plan due: Last chance for bee...

Environment Secretary Elizabeth Truss is launching the National Pollinator ...


4 November 2014 | Arable
Experts welcome financial boost for youn...

Experts welcome financial boost for youn...

Agricultural specialists have welcomed a potential financial boost for youn...


3 November 2014 | News
Supermarket competition on prices 'risks...

Supermarket competition on prices 'risks...

As retailers continue to participate in a highly competitive race to the bo...


31 October 2014 | Arable
New Defra farm figures 'underline volati...

New Defra farm figures 'underline volati...

New farm business income data from Defra, which focus on income from March ...


30 October 2014 | Agri Safety
Agriculture remains one of UK's most dan...

Agriculture remains one of UK's most dan...

Agriculture has remained one of the industries in which workers are most li...


29 October 2014 | Finance
UK farmland prices see 'substantial grow...

UK farmland prices see 'substantial grow...

Prime arable land in the UK has seen a substantial year-on-year growth in p...


27 October 2014 | Arable
Satellites to help farmers pinpoint dise...

Satellites to help farmers pinpoint dise...

A new mobile app for farmers able to pinpoint and identify disease, pests a...