25 May 2015 | Online since 2003



Research reveals level of illegal badger culling


Over 10% of livestock farmers in Wales have illegally killed badgers according to a research paper published today.

Using a method known as the randomised reponse technique (RRT), the research team suggested that it would be interesting to model how such a rate of illegal badger killing could be contributing, or not, to the spread of bTB, particularly as badger movements are effected when social groups are disrupted.

Farming Minister David Heath hinted the badger cull could resume in other areas after a delay was announced by the government last October.

Plans for a badger cull in Somerset and Gloucestershire were due to go ahead until it was stopped amid widespread criticisms, protests and petitions.

The paper, called 'Innovative techniques for estimating illegal activities in a human-wildlife-management conflict', by teams from the Bangor University, University of Kent and Kingston University revealed the estimated rate of illegal culling.

Previous research does not sufficiently consider whether illegal badger killing contributes to the spread of bovine tuberculosis (bTB) to livestock.

"The proportion of farmers estimated to have killed badgers should be considered by policymakers and in the wider debate" said Dr Paul Cross, from Bangor University.

"Intensive badger culling is one approach being considered by policy makers in an attempt to control the spread of tuberculosis in cattle."

"However, studies investigating the effects of badger culling on TB outbreaks in cattle have not factored in the prevalence of illegal badger killing, and its potential to spread disease."

Dr Freya St John, from the University of Kent said: "Attempting to resolve the issues regarding badgers as carriers of bovine TB requires cross-disciplinary scientific research, a departure from deep-rooted positions, and the political will to implement evidence-based management. We believe that this study makes an important contribution to that debate."

RRT requires respondents to roll two dice before answering sensitive questions such as ‘have you killed a badger in the last 12 months’.

The result of the dice roll is never revealed to researchers, it is the respondents’ secret.

Crucially there are instructions associated with the dice roll, for example, if the sum of the dice equals five through to ten, answer truthfully; if the sum is between 2 and 4, answer 'yes'; and if the sum is 11 or 12, answer 'no'.

The role of 'forced' answers adds noise to the data so that a 'yes' answer doesn’t necessarily mean that a respondent committed an illegal act.

After the delay last year, the NFU wrote to the Environment Secretary Owen Paterson to urge the operation to commence in 2013.

Environment Secretary Owen Paterson said: "Despite a greatly increased effort over the last few days and weeks, the farmers delivering this policy have concluded that they cannot be confident that it will be possible to remove enough badgers based on these higher numbers and considering the lateness of the season."

"The Government is determined to tackle bovine TB by all the means available to us. Now, in the next few months, we will ensure that the pilot culls can be implemented effectively, in the best possible conditions, with the right resources."

The President of the British Veterinary Association said the halt was a 'severe blow' to the vets and farmers who are battling against bovine TB.

"We need to wait for the Secretary of State’s statement to hear the reasons behind any delay, and we very much hope this will not reflect a change in policy" said Peter Jones.

"As we get later in the season we must recognise that it becomes less likely for a cull to be delivered effectively and so it could make sense to delay until next year."

"It is important to note that the speculation is that the cull is being delayed due to questions surrounding the logistics of delivery. The science has not changed."

Download




Comments


24-01-2013 11:16 AM | Posted by: Graham
This brilliant piece of research work indicates that many farmers are committing crimes almost guaranteed to increase the spread of bTB.

Just wait for their screams of indignation if protesters are seen to break the law.

To post comment without approval login or register

Display name

Please enter your name

Email (optional)
Comment

Please enter your comment

Post Comment

Your comment submitted successfully.Please wait for admin approval.

Some error on your process.Please try one more time.



Jobs


11 May 2015
Harvest Students Herts/Essex Border
Accommodation will be in mobile homes on one of the farms; Our client with 4,000 acres of combinable crops around Bishop's St...

13 May 2015
Legal Secretary
Liaising with dairy organiser to ensure matters are covered. My client is looking to recruit a Legal Secretary on a permanent...

7 May 2015
Litigation Solicitor (ref 021-LTN)
Our Agriculture and Private Client team currently comprises 16 people in total. Litigation Solicitor Location:....

15 May 2015
Regional Manager - Industrial
Regional/Branch Manager - Agriculture | Warehousing | Logistics - Lincolnshire. Up to £45k Basic Salary....

8 May 2015
Junior Category Manager – The Midlands
The successful applicant will support the Category Manager in the day to day management of the Agriculture category....



Top stories you may have missed
15 May 2015 | Arable

Scotland’s Rural Affairs Secretary Richard Lochhead is calling on the Europ...


15 May 2015 | Finance

As the country settles down following the turmoil of the general election, ...


14 May 2015 | Animal Health

New research from the Universities of Bristol and Cambridge has found that ...


13 May 2015 | Animal Health

A new publication to help farmers prevent sheep lameness and offer advice o...


12 May 2015 | Agri Safety

The Farmers’ Union of Wales is putting the spotlight on Liver fluke at next...


5 May 2015 | News

The UK is now third in the global rankings for utility-scale solar energy a...


29 April 2015 | Agri Safety

A recent Rural Watch demonstration and information event gave Farmers’ Unio...


24 April 2015 | Meat Processing

Retailers should confirm their commitments to sourcing UK lamb this season,...


15 April 2015 | Meat Processing

A leading retailer has apologised after selling imported lamb in a Borders ...


9 April 2015 | Finance

The time has come for landlords to expect to see reductions in farm rents, ...