HROC (agency) - Kubota
Farminguk
30 August 2016 | Online since 2003
Briefing Media - FG Classified


15 January 2013 06:47:16 |

Restrictions on neonicotinoid 'would put £630m at risk'


A comprehensive review of the value of neonicotinoid seed treatment released today in Brussels has prompted further concerns from UK agriculture about the proposed restrictions on its use.
The 'Humboldt Forum for Food and Agriculture' report (which can be downloaded at the bottom of the page) says that if UK farmers no longer had access to the seed treatment, it would result in a loss of approximately £630 million to the economy each year.
The report suggests significant implications for the winter wheat sector, where many farmers depend on neonicotinoids as the most effective method for controlling seasonal pests (particularly aphids) and managing the farming operations needed to produce the crop throughout the year.
If UK farmers no longer had access to neonicotinoid technology, the authors of the report conclude that this could lead to:
- Yield declines of up to 20%, which could make winter wheat an unprofitable crop for many UK farmers, and its production unfeasible in high-pest pressure areas.
- A loss of up to £630 million approx. (€782 million) each year to the UK economy.
- Threats to 1,300 jobs that have been directly created in the UK by neonicotinoids, and income loss for a further 15,000 growers.
In addition, world market prices for crop commodities could increase by up to two percent if an EU-wide suspension on neonicotinoids was introduced, the report found.
"At a time of increasing world commodity market volatility, any additional upward price pressures will impact on overall food inflation whilst at the same time negatively impacting on the UK farmers’ ability to produce crops to the highest economic and environmental standards" said Paul Rooke from the Agricultural Industries Confederation.
In Brussels, the report was launched with the support of The European Seed Association, Copa-Cogeca and the European Crop Protection Association, against a backdrop of concern about calls for further restrictions across the EU, following a suspension on the use of neonicotinoids in France last year.
The debate has been sparked by concerns for the health of bee populations, despite extensive scientific and field evidence which has found no reason to restrict the treatments' use.
Neonicotinoids are critical for successful, profitable production of winter wheat, oilseed rape (OSR), barley and sugar beet in the UK, and for corn, sunflowers and vegetable crops across the EU.
"As well as lower yields and revenue losses, UK crushers and processors, who currently source from UK providers exclusively, may be forced to make good any stock shortfall by importing crops from abroad" said UK OSR sector, Chris Baldwin, Managing Director of United Oilseeds.
"Using neonicotinoids as a seed coating is the most effective way to apply insecticide to crops and target specific threats."
"The alternative means having to spray post-emergent crops with insecticide in the field. As well as being less effective, this method is less targeted and means higher input costs for farmers."
"As a co-operative with over 3,500 farmer members, the welfare of the countryside and the environment is at the core of our ethos. But we recognise pest control is an essential part of bringing sustainable, assured, healthy crops to the marketplace and consumers" he said.
NFU lead on bee health Dr Chris Hartfield said: "The results of this work are important, particularly in light of work being done currently by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) reviewing neonicotinoid seed treatments."
"While EFSA’s work has identified gaps in the current regulatory process assessing how pesticides affect bees, we still do not know how relevant these gaps are and whether plugging them would actually improve the health of bees or other pollinators."
"Any decision to change the way pesticides are used to control crop pests will have an impact on both the protection of insect pollinators and the protection of crops."
The report also found:
- The productivity gap created by loss of this technology could only be closed by bringing into production an additional 3 million hectares of land outside of Europe at a cost of 600m tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions
- Neonicotinoids contribute over £1.6 billion approx. (€2 billion) annually to commodity crop revenues and reduce production costs by £800 million approx. (€1 billion) across the EU compared to alternatives
- The true annual economic benefit of neonicotinoids to the grower, when compared to not using pesticides at all, is over £3.2 billion approx. (€4 billion)
- In total, over a five year period, EU potential wealth could erode by up to £13.8 billion approx. (€17 billion) as the result of further restrictions, putting the jobs of over a million people engaged in arable production across the EU at risk
- As many as 50,000 farm jobs could be affected across the EU if the technology was no longer available
"This report shows that the loss of neonicotinoid seed treatment would seriously damage sustainable food production in Europe" said Steffen Noleppa (agripol), one of the authors of the report.
"For the first time, we have been able to quantify the socio-economic and environmental value of this transformative technology and found that without it, crop yields would be significantly lower and grower margins would be eroded, in some cases irreversibly."
"Our report found that the consequence of such a ban for wider society could include lower crop yields, leading to higher commodity prices."

Download

2 Comments

loginuserlogo
Name

Please enter your name


Email

Please enter your email

Please enter valid email


Comment

Please enter your comment


Post Comment

Your comment has been submitted successfully. Please wait for admin approval.


Comments


Thailand | 30 August 2016
Overworked Agriculture minister wants a deputy

Agriculture Minister Chatchai Sarikulya has confirmed he wants a deputy minister appointed to share the growing workload at the Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives. Gen Chatchai said this when...


USA | 30 August 2016
Washington state begins killing wolf pack for preying on livestock

Wildlife agents authorized to eradicate a group of 11 wolves for repeated attacks on cattle in Washington state have hunted down and killed six animals from the condemned pack and are searching for th...


Ireland | 30 August 2016
Farm bodies clash on EU dairy package

The IFA and ICMSA have clashed on how a new €22m support package for the dairy sector should be spent. While IFA has suggested that the aid package be used to guarantee low interest farmer loans, I...


Australia | 30 August 2016
Beef soon to become a 'luxury item' as prices skyrocket

For many Aussies, splurging on a ribeye may be a thing of the past, as a global beef shortage has sent shockwaves through meat markets, sending menu prices soaring and diners out the door. Since th...


USA | 30 August 2016
In drought, drones help California farmers save every drop

A drone whirred to life in a cloud of dust, then shot hundreds of feet skyward for a bird's-eye view of a vast tomato field in California's Central Valley, the nation's most productive farming region....



Trending Now

Viewed
Discussed


Top stories you may have missed
FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

A new survey has revealed that the vast majority of British consumers belie...


FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

The British public are overwhelmingly in favour of keeping or strengthening...


FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

The sustained recovery of pig prices since the spring has come at a time wh...


FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

A World Trade Organisation (WTO) panel has declared the Russian import ban ...


FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

A new study has linked oilseed rape crops grown from neonicotinoid-treated ...


FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

Philip Hammond is to guarantee billions of pounds of UK government investme...


FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

Access to the foreign labour market is 'critical', according the chief exec...


FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

The Tenant Farmers Association has said the National Trust's vision for a p...


FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

Ulster farmers will 'not lie down and wave the white flag' when Brexit nego...


FarmingUK
FarmingUK Logo

FarmingUK

The cost of rural crime to the UK economy costs £42.5 million a year, accor...


closeicon
Username
Password