Welsh government upland proposals flawed, NFU says

NFU Cymru President Stephen James has expressed deep disappointment at the recent announcement by Deputy Minister for Farming and Food, Rebecca Evans AM, that there will be no Area of Natural Constraint (ANC) Scheme in Wales.

Speaking at today’s NFU Cymru Council meeting in Cardiff, Stephen James said, “It has been the long-held view of NFU Cymru that the industry must be supported by the introduction of a dedicated ANC Scheme for the uplands, which allows payments to farmers to reflect the additional costs of farming in these naturally disadvantaged areas. The decision is particularly disappointing as we have just returned from Brussels, where we learned that many other Member States are taking forward this measure to support their upland farming sectors.

“The decision also flies in the face of the comprehensive evidence base and clear recommendation for a dedicated scheme put forward by the Uplands Forum in their report ‘Unlocking the potential of the Uplands’.

“Proposals for the Welsh uplands as they currently stand are flawed and the impacts will be felt by farmers across Wales. The EU Regulation allows Member States to differentiate the level of ANC payment taking into account the farming system and we would ask why Welsh Government has not considered how this flexibility could be deployed to target upland support.

“Rather than dedicate a proportion of the RDP budget currently allocated to land based measures to an ANC Scheme, as NFU Cymru have argued for, Welsh Government appear to be proposing to prioritise elements relating to young farmers and capital investment to upland areas, this is not the right way to go, these type of projects should be assessed on their individual merits regardless of location.”


Mr James ended, “We have long argued that the two Pillars of CAP should be used in a complimentary way and the RDP offers the opportunity to put in place a wide range of measures to support and enhance competitiveness and farm viability across Wales. The failure of Welsh Government to adopt a ‘right measure-right location’ approach can only serve to limit the impact and effectiveness of RDP measures overall, particularly in upland areas where agriculture has to be viable to deliver the wide range of environmental, social and cultural benefits that society expects.”