Saturday 26 May 2012
Headlines
Did you find this story interesting? (0) (0)
30/05/2008 14:54:59
CLA says Pirbright decision disrespects rural economy
A disturbing lack of respect for the rural economy is shown by the decision not to prosecute following the outbreak of foot and mouth disease at the Pirbright laboratory in Surrey, says the CLA.
The rural economy experts warn that the decision will set "a dangerous precedent" in similar situations involving public bodies in future.
Country Land & Business Association deputy president William Worsley said: "This is extremely worrying when you are talking about something as potentially devastating as animal disease. This decision will set a dangerous precedent for similar situations caused by the negligence of public bodies.
"It suggests public bodies are not subject to the same level of accountability as everyone else. This is despite a seemingly endless stream of regulations affecting rural businesses that makes managers ever more accountable for their actions."
The decision not to prosecute the Institute of Animal Health and private company Merial, which share the site at Pirbright, has been taken because Surrey County Council said it has been unable to identify the exact source. The Council felt it could not bring a prosecution against either body because of lack of evidence.
The official report concluded that live FMD virus leaked from faulty pipes and spread from the Pirbright site. Livestock on eight farms was infected, and the farming industry lost an estimated £100million through loss of sales, movement restrictions and extra feed costs.
The CLA deputy president added: "The most recent inquiry into the outbreak, by Iain Anderson who led the review into the 2001 foot and mouth crisis, called for clarity of responsibility and ownership at Pirbright.
"He attacked the 'creeping degradation of standards' at the site which he described as 'shabby and dilapidated' and criticised a number of bodies, including Defra, the official regulator at that time, and the Institute of Animal Health. Nonetheless there are to be no prosecutions – this is deplorable."
The rural economy experts warn that the decision will set "a dangerous precedent" in similar situations involving public bodies in future.
Country Land & Business Association deputy president William Worsley said: "This is extremely worrying when you are talking about something as potentially devastating as animal disease. This decision will set a dangerous precedent for similar situations caused by the negligence of public bodies.
"It suggests public bodies are not subject to the same level of accountability as everyone else. This is despite a seemingly endless stream of regulations affecting rural businesses that makes managers ever more accountable for their actions."
The decision not to prosecute the Institute of Animal Health and private company Merial, which share the site at Pirbright, has been taken because Surrey County Council said it has been unable to identify the exact source. The Council felt it could not bring a prosecution against either body because of lack of evidence.
The official report concluded that live FMD virus leaked from faulty pipes and spread from the Pirbright site. Livestock on eight farms was infected, and the farming industry lost an estimated £100million through loss of sales, movement restrictions and extra feed costs.
The CLA deputy president added: "The most recent inquiry into the outbreak, by Iain Anderson who led the review into the 2001 foot and mouth crisis, called for clarity of responsibility and ownership at Pirbright.
"He attacked the 'creeping degradation of standards' at the site which he described as 'shabby and dilapidated' and criticised a number of bodies, including Defra, the official regulator at that time, and the Institute of Animal Health. Nonetheless there are to be no prosecutions – this is deplorable."
No Comments
Nobody has posted any comments on this story.
|
Farming items for Sale
|
Valtra 8150 HiTech - MAGHREA(GBP 18840)
New Holland TS 100 - Huntingdon
(Price on Application)
(Price on Application)
Renault - Ceres 335X - Carnforth
(Price on Application)
(Price on Application)
Used Massey Ferguson 2008 MF6480 - Grantham
(Price on Application)
(Price on Application)
Massey Ferguson 6480-4 - Cirencester
(Price on Application)
(Price on Application)
Related News
CLA Rural Economy Index reveals higher confidence in rural economy - 07 Jan 2009Confidence in the rural economy is higher than in the economy as a whole, according to the new quarterly CLA Rural Economy Index – the CLA REI. The...
CLA Game Fair 2010 set to boost Warwickshire’s rural economy - 20 Aug 2009The CLA Game Fair 2010 will be held at Ragley Hall, near Alcester, Warwickshire from Friday 23 to Sunday 25 July 2010. Ragley Hall is a new and exc...
CLA discuss politicians record on rural economy - 26 Jul 2010The CLA President’s Debate at the CLA Game Fair, looked at the question: "A Coalition for the Countryside – Can Politics Deliver for the Rural E...
Planning policy 'too cautious' for rural economy - CLA - 24 May 2011The CLA today said a draft National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) is too cautious for the needs of the rural economy. The Association said whil...
Regulation Reduction Crucial For Rural Economic Viability – Says CLA - 17 Jan 2008The Government's Better Regulation Executive must minimise bureaucracy for rural-based businesses - particularly in the planning system where it c...
Welcome progress for rural planning, says CLA - 17 Jan 2008The CLA, the rural economy experts, has welcomed the publication of the Government's Planning Policy Statement Planning and Climate Change, and al...
Government must reconnect with rural businesses, says CLA after CRC report response - 06 Feb 2009The Government response to the Commission for Rural Communities (CRC) report by the Rural Advocate on the impact of the recession on the rural economy...
Report is a shot in the arm for hard-pressed rural businesses, says CLA - 25 Mar 2009The CLA’s belief that rural businesses are being held back by a poor planning system has been supported by today’s Government response to ...
The CLA says Lord Carter’s Digital Britain report ‘fails to understand rural needs’ - 16 Jun 2009The CLA said Lord Carter’s long-awaited Digital Britain report finally recognises the UK is at "a tipping point" for broadband coverage – but st...
Fuel Tax Hike widens Rural/Urban Divide says CLA North - 07 Sep 2009The CLA in the North says that this month’s increase in fuel duty has again highlighted how much people and businesses in the countryside are de...
