Saturday 04 February 2012
Headlines
Did you find this story interesting? (0) (0)
05/11/2009 08:58:41
Cultural practices no substitute for loss of products
At the 46th BCPC Annual Weed Review, held at the PGRO, Peterborough on 4 November 2009, a clear message was given – "there are no existing cultural control methods which can fully compensate for the loss of cereal grass weed herbicides, resulting from the lack of new products coming forward, and the removal of key products by EU legislation. But there are methods which can support the performance of products that are still available."
In a review of work conducted over the last forty years, Dr Peter Lutman and Dr Stephen Moss of Rothamsted Research revealed that, in general, cultural control was less effective, more variable and more expensive than using herbicides. For example, the most effective agronomic practices can only achieve 70% to 80% control of black-grass – compared with 90% control given by the best herbicides. However, the more effective cultural practices can help to control grass weeds, even with a depleted range of chemicals.
"Using appropriate cultural practices can take the pressure off herbicides," said Dr Lutman. "The current techniques of; non-inversion tillage, early planting, very low crop seed rates and continuous winter cropping, all put huge pressure on herbicides. This approach will not succeed in the future when fewer products are available, and if grass weed resistance becomes more of a problem than it is today".
Major adjustments will need to be made in farming practices including, for example, rotational ploughing and spring crops in the rotation. "If we do not change the way we grow our cereals, we run the risk that they will be overwhelmed by unmanageable grass weeds in the not too distant future" said Dr Lutman.
Mark Ballingall, Senior Weeds Consultant at the Scottish Agricultural College (SAC) demonstrated the significant impact that the EU91/414, Water Framework and Drinking Water directives have on weed control in potatoes. Reduced rates of linuron and metribuzin – used on 66% and 26% of the crop area respectively – and the absence of new pre-emergence products to substitute them, could result in 10% yield losses, costing the industry £100m per annum. "A move to post-emergence products will not be helpful – bentazon will also be deregistered, and the one remaining post-emergence product, rimsulfuron has limited weed spectrum and cannot be applied to seed crops," said Dr Ballingall.
"The results of the studies reported at this year’s review are further evidence that the EU Commission’s claims – that new chemical products, or non-chemical methods, will make up for the loss of key crop protection products – are misleading, certainly in the all important area of weed control" said The Arable Group’s (TAG) David Parish, chairman of the Review. "It is clear that major changes will need to be implemented; including a significant increase in cultivation operations. As was shown at the 2007 Weeds Review, by Drs. Wilson and Sparkes from Nottingham University, these can dramatically increase both the carbon footprint and costs of cereal and especially potato production".
BCPC, in cooperation with other agricultural and horticultural organisations, will be holding a series of workshops during the next two years to address the problems resulting from the raft of EU legislation. "These will bring together all interested players; regulators, advisors, researchers, levy board representatives and agronomists to act in a concerted fashion" said BCPC Chairman Dr Colin Ruscoe. "They will investigate the full range of possible actions to find ways for farmers and growers to meet the challenge of increasing food production by sustainable intensification, despite the loss of key herbicides and other pesticides".
In a review of work conducted over the last forty years, Dr Peter Lutman and Dr Stephen Moss of Rothamsted Research revealed that, in general, cultural control was less effective, more variable and more expensive than using herbicides. For example, the most effective agronomic practices can only achieve 70% to 80% control of black-grass – compared with 90% control given by the best herbicides. However, the more effective cultural practices can help to control grass weeds, even with a depleted range of chemicals.
"Using appropriate cultural practices can take the pressure off herbicides," said Dr Lutman. "The current techniques of; non-inversion tillage, early planting, very low crop seed rates and continuous winter cropping, all put huge pressure on herbicides. This approach will not succeed in the future when fewer products are available, and if grass weed resistance becomes more of a problem than it is today".
Major adjustments will need to be made in farming practices including, for example, rotational ploughing and spring crops in the rotation. "If we do not change the way we grow our cereals, we run the risk that they will be overwhelmed by unmanageable grass weeds in the not too distant future" said Dr Lutman.
Mark Ballingall, Senior Weeds Consultant at the Scottish Agricultural College (SAC) demonstrated the significant impact that the EU91/414, Water Framework and Drinking Water directives have on weed control in potatoes. Reduced rates of linuron and metribuzin – used on 66% and 26% of the crop area respectively – and the absence of new pre-emergence products to substitute them, could result in 10% yield losses, costing the industry £100m per annum. "A move to post-emergence products will not be helpful – bentazon will also be deregistered, and the one remaining post-emergence product, rimsulfuron has limited weed spectrum and cannot be applied to seed crops," said Dr Ballingall.
"The results of the studies reported at this year’s review are further evidence that the EU Commission’s claims – that new chemical products, or non-chemical methods, will make up for the loss of key crop protection products – are misleading, certainly in the all important area of weed control" said The Arable Group’s (TAG) David Parish, chairman of the Review. "It is clear that major changes will need to be implemented; including a significant increase in cultivation operations. As was shown at the 2007 Weeds Review, by Drs. Wilson and Sparkes from Nottingham University, these can dramatically increase both the carbon footprint and costs of cereal and especially potato production".
BCPC, in cooperation with other agricultural and horticultural organisations, will be holding a series of workshops during the next two years to address the problems resulting from the raft of EU legislation. "These will bring together all interested players; regulators, advisors, researchers, levy board representatives and agronomists to act in a concerted fashion" said BCPC Chairman Dr Colin Ruscoe. "They will investigate the full range of possible actions to find ways for farmers and growers to meet the challenge of increasing food production by sustainable intensification, despite the loss of key herbicides and other pesticides".
No Comments
Nobody has posted any comments on this story.
|
Farming items for Sale
|
Kubota B1500 - Great Horkesley
(Price on Application)
(Price on Application)
Steyr CVT170 - Kendal(GBP 36000)
Valtra N101h - Lerwick(GBP 38188)
Deutz Commander 605 - Penrith(GBP 7680)
Valtra 6300 - Dalbeattie(GBP 27300)
Related News
Proposed EU pesticide legislation could lead to loss of most UK-approved products - 11 Jun 2008Yields will be decimated, many crops will become uneconomical to produce and food quality will be threatened if new legislation proposed by the EU Com...
Integrating cultural and chemical control in carrots - 19 Mar 2010With Sclerotinia being such a widespread and serious disease of carrots, growers are using complementary ways of reducing disease risk by integrating ...
No substitute for good agronomy - 02 Mar 2011When it comes to fertiliser agronomy, timing and spreading are relatively easy to manage but selecting the optimum N rate can be more difficult. As AD...
Environmental sound farming practices can help farm profitability while reducing environmental impacts - 05 Jul 2004Barbara Young, Chief Executive of the Environment Agency, at this year's Royal Show will tell how the environment is not a cost or burden, but can pro...
Regions should share best practice - Sir Don Curry - 08 Apr 2004Sir Don Curry, author of the Curry Report, is backing a major new feature at this year's Royal Show, which will bring to life the Government's Strateg...
Suffolk college practices what it preaches - 03 May 2003A Suffolk agricultural college has announced plans to practice what is teaching many of the county's hard-pressed arable and pig farmers - invest ...
Best practice on pesticide handling areas - 18 Apr 2005New guidance on handling of pesticides and disposal of spray washings is hot off the press from the Environment Agency and the Crop Protection Associa...
New snares code of practice emphasises animal welfare - 20 Oct 2005A new code of practice on the use of snares was launched today, with a strong emphasis on animal welfare when people are considering the use of snare...
Putting stewardship into practice - 24 Apr 2006Cambridgeshire potato grower Matthew Murfitt is finding the latest nematicide stewardship guidelines take no extra time or effort to put into practice...
NFU welcomes new metal detecting code of practice - 02 May 2006The NFU has welcomed the launch of the new Code of Practice for Responsible Metal Detecting in England and Wales. The voluntary code of practice is...
