Sunday 27 May 2012
Headlines
Did you find this story interesting? (0) (0)
25/01/2007
NFU condemns 'wrong and perverse' ASA ruling on anti-meat campaign
The NFU has said the Advertising Standards Authority made a wrong and perverse decision in failing to uphold complaints about the animal rights activist group PETA's advertising campaign in which it claimed feeding meat to children was tantamount to child abuse.
The NFU was one of a number of organisations and members of the public who complained to the ASA about the PETA campaign when it was launched last year. The complaint was based on the facts:
There is no evidence that meat is a contributory factor to childhood obesity,
the advertisement trivialised child abuse and would be deeply offensive to child abuse victims and their families, and
the campaign was insulting and offensive to the meat-eating majority of parents.
The NFU put in a detailed argument to the ASA, setting out how the PETA advert breached 13 clauses of the code governing such adverts, including arguments that the advert:
was misleading,
was intended to shock consumers, and
was irresponsible in that it encouraged parents to make drastic changes in their children's diets without first taking talking to a doctor or nutritionist.
However despite all of the evidence the ASA decided not to uphold the complaints, on the grounds that PETA was an overtly vegetarian organisation that was to be expected to say that meat was bad for children and that, because of this, the information in the ads would be either discounted or not taken seriously by consumers.
A spokesman for the NFU said: "The ASA decision is wrong and perverse. The implication of this ruling is that any extremist organisation can say what it likes because the fact that it is extremist means its material will not be taken seriously.
"The implication is that there is one rule for responsible organisations and another for the lunatic fringe, who can basically say what they like.
"The fact of the matter is there is no ground for arguing that eating meat does, of itself, contribute to childhood obesity and for PETA to claim otherwise is both wrong and potentially damaging to health.
"We cannot accept this ruling, both because it is plainly perverse and mistaken and also because of the precedent it could set for other fringe organisations who might want to frighten the public into supporting their cause by publishing false and malicious information.
"For all of these reasons, we will be lodging a request for an Independent Review at the earliest opportunity"
 |
The NFU was one of a number of organisations and members of the public who complained to the ASA about the PETA campaign when it was launched last year. The complaint was based on the facts:
There is no evidence that meat is a contributory factor to childhood obesity,
the advertisement trivialised child abuse and would be deeply offensive to child abuse victims and their families, and
the campaign was insulting and offensive to the meat-eating majority of parents.
The NFU put in a detailed argument to the ASA, setting out how the PETA advert breached 13 clauses of the code governing such adverts, including arguments that the advert:
was misleading,
was intended to shock consumers, and
was irresponsible in that it encouraged parents to make drastic changes in their children's diets without first taking talking to a doctor or nutritionist.
However despite all of the evidence the ASA decided not to uphold the complaints, on the grounds that PETA was an overtly vegetarian organisation that was to be expected to say that meat was bad for children and that, because of this, the information in the ads would be either discounted or not taken seriously by consumers.
A spokesman for the NFU said: "The ASA decision is wrong and perverse. The implication of this ruling is that any extremist organisation can say what it likes because the fact that it is extremist means its material will not be taken seriously.
"The implication is that there is one rule for responsible organisations and another for the lunatic fringe, who can basically say what they like.
"The fact of the matter is there is no ground for arguing that eating meat does, of itself, contribute to childhood obesity and for PETA to claim otherwise is both wrong and potentially damaging to health.
"We cannot accept this ruling, both because it is plainly perverse and mistaken and also because of the precedent it could set for other fringe organisations who might want to frighten the public into supporting their cause by publishing false and malicious information.
"For all of these reasons, we will be lodging a request for an Independent Review at the earliest opportunity"
No Comments
Nobody has posted any comments on this story.
|
Farming items for Sale
|
Zetor 8540 - Chulmleigh(GBP 12000)
Case 1394 2wd Tractor - York(GBP 3000)
Used Massey Ferguson 690 - York(GBP 6500)
Massey Ferguson 6485 - Maidstone(GBP 30900)
Fendt 930 - Bruton(GBP 98000)
Related News
NFU Cymru Condemns Attack On Livestock Farmer - 10 Jun 2007NFU has strongly condemned the reported actions of the 'Animal Liberation Front' who have claimed responsibility for an attack on a livestock ...
Natural England takes wrong turning on coastal access - NFU - 15 Feb 2007Natural England's plans for creating a statutory right of access to coastal land have been sharply criticised by the NFU as being a recipe for con...
Philiipines-Condemned Meat getting into food chain. - 16 Mar 2009PHILIPPINES-CONDEMNED MAT GETS IN FOOD CHAIN. THE GOVERNMENT will now go after the sources of "double dead" meat to protect consumers and ...
Campaigners slam ASA digital remit extension - 01 Sep 2010Children’s health campaigners warned today that the Advertising Standards Authority’s new remit to cover companies’ "own marketing c...
ASA rejects frozen veg claims for nutritional benefits - 18 Aug 2011The Fresh Produce Consortium (FPC) has welcomed the Advertising Standards Agency’s confirmation that advertisers cannot claim that frozen vegeta...
US-EU soybean trade heavy-handed - ASA - 08 Feb 2012As United States Trade Representative Ron Kirk moves to consider ways to improve the nation’s trade relationship with the European Union (EU) as...
ASA points to biodiesel before Senate committee - 17 Feb 2012In comments submitted Wednesday, the American Soybean Association (ASA) pointed to the record-setting production of biodiesel from American soy, as we...
ASA cheers upcoming Korea trade agreement - 22 Feb 2012The American Soybean Association (ASA) congratulates President Barack Obama and the administration for completing its review of the free trade agreeme...
ASA Celebrates National Agriculture Day - 07 Mar 2012The American Soybean Association (ASA) is proud to join its colleagues and counterparts in the agriculture industry as it celebrates National Agricult...
ASA’s Wellman testifies on Soybean Farm Bill priorities - 15 Mar 2012The importance of passing a farm bill this year, a comprehensive and revenue-based safety net, the integrity of crop insurance, and the critical need ...
