Sunday 27 May 2012
Headlines
Did you find this story interesting? (0) (0)
11/09/2007
Virus leak from Pirbright site is a scandal
The Tenant Farmers Association has reacted with anger to the reports of the Health and Safety Executive and Professor Brian Spratt, of Imperial College London, into the recent outbreak of Foot and Mouth Disease in Surrey which point the finger of blame at inadequate standards of repair, maintenance and bio-security at the Government-controlled site at Pirbright which houses the Institute for Animal Health and Merial, a commercial animal health company.
TFA National Chairman Reg Haydon said, "This is clearly a scandal. I can't help thinking that if these reports had been written about a farm at the centre of an FMD outbreak then the Government would have moved quickly to introduce draconian measures to increase farm bio-security across the board, more heavily restrict animal movements and would be seeking recompense from the industry for the Government's costs in controlling the outbreak. That the Government should have left a leaking pipe un-repaired, knowing full well that it was used for live FMD virus, is inexcusable."
"The Government has been praised for the speed at which it has tackled this outbreak. However, now we know that it was caused by the Government in the first place it puts the whole saga into a very different perspective. The trauma that has been caused to those who have lost their livestock and the major upheaval and loss experienced by the rest of the livestock industry through the necessary movement controls has been a heavy cost to bear. We were all fortunate that the site at the centre of the outbreak was not situated in a part of the country more densely populated with livestock and that it did not get into sheep or pigs – the consequences of those scenarios would have been unthinkable," said Mr Haydon.
"Livestock farmers across the country will now want to know how their losses will be covered. Those who have been culled out will have the clearest cases but the TFA is discussing with its legal advisers, Bircham Dyson Bell in London, potential claims from other farmers who have had losses as a result of the control mechanisms that had to be introduced. Given the Government's culpability we hope that it will look upon such claims sympathetically," said Mr Haydon.
TFA National Chairman Reg Haydon said, "This is clearly a scandal. I can't help thinking that if these reports had been written about a farm at the centre of an FMD outbreak then the Government would have moved quickly to introduce draconian measures to increase farm bio-security across the board, more heavily restrict animal movements and would be seeking recompense from the industry for the Government's costs in controlling the outbreak. That the Government should have left a leaking pipe un-repaired, knowing full well that it was used for live FMD virus, is inexcusable."
"The Government has been praised for the speed at which it has tackled this outbreak. However, now we know that it was caused by the Government in the first place it puts the whole saga into a very different perspective. The trauma that has been caused to those who have lost their livestock and the major upheaval and loss experienced by the rest of the livestock industry through the necessary movement controls has been a heavy cost to bear. We were all fortunate that the site at the centre of the outbreak was not situated in a part of the country more densely populated with livestock and that it did not get into sheep or pigs – the consequences of those scenarios would have been unthinkable," said Mr Haydon.
"Livestock farmers across the country will now want to know how their losses will be covered. Those who have been culled out will have the clearest cases but the TFA is discussing with its legal advisers, Bircham Dyson Bell in London, potential claims from other farmers who have had losses as a result of the control mechanisms that had to be introduced. Given the Government's culpability we hope that it will look upon such claims sympathetically," said Mr Haydon.
No Comments
Nobody has posted any comments on this story.
|
Farming items for Sale
|
John Deere 6920 - Peterborough(GBP 32700)
Massey Ferguson 5455 - 4wd Tractor - Ayr(GBP 19500)
Massey Ferguson 375 - Lancaster
(Price on Application)
(Price on Application)
Case International 5130 - York
(Price on Application)
(Price on Application)
Fendt 415 - Newry(GBP 64000)
Related News
Next livestock virus targeted for eradication could be peste des petits ruminants virus - 01 Jul 2011In a scientific editorial in Veterinary Record to be published today, top researchers have said that the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) and t...
Leaked EU paper reveals cloned food restrictions were possible - 11 May 2011As raised during debate in the European Parliament this afternoon, BEUC and the Eurogroup for Animals are bewildered by a confidential document from t...
Leaked proposals for the reform of CAP entitlements – leave a narrow window for restructuring farm businesses - 16 Aug 2011News has recently been leaked from the European Commission that farmers who claim more than €150,000 from the direct support element of the CAP (Pilla...
New Can-Am ATV riding gear range - 30 Jan 2007NEW CAN-AM ATV RIDING GEAR RANGE The new Can-Am(T) clothing range, designed especially for the ATV rider, is available from authorised Can-Am deale...
Pembrokehshire farmers meet local AM - 22 Nov 2007"Farmgate beef and lamb prices need to increase substantially to ensure the long term viability of livestock production in Pembrokeshire," Perkin Evan...
Pirbright foot and mouth report is shocking - Webb - 12 Mar 2008Responding to the findings of the independent inquiry into the foot-and-mouth outbreak last year at Pirbright, Liberal Democrat Shadow Defra Secre...
CLA says Pirbright decision disrespects rural economy - 30 May 2008A disturbing lack of respect for the rural economy is shown by the decision not to prosecute following the outbreak of foot and mouth disease at the P...
Pirbright development welcomed - 25 Aug 2009The Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) has welcomed a Government decision to invest in the redevelopment of the animal dis...
FUW welcomes AM's report on Glastir - 03 Mar 2010The Farmers’ Union of Wales today welcomed the conclusions of the Assembly’s rural development sub-committee’s inquiry into the new ...
FUW members tell AM of TB cull delay worries - 15 Sep 2011Farmers’ Union of Wales members in Carmarthenshire expressed their concerns at the Welsh Government’s failure to drive the bovine TB eradi...
