UK govt has 'failed to enable real progress' on post-Brexit farming deal

Scotland’s rural affairs secretary Fergus Ewing has criticised the UK government's lack of clarity over a post-Brexit farm deal
Scotland’s rural affairs secretary Fergus Ewing has criticised the UK government's lack of clarity over a post-Brexit farm deal

There has been no progress in arrangements for agricultural industry for when the UK leaves the EU, according to Scotland’s rural affairs secretary.

Fergus Ewing, speaking after a devolved administration meeting with UK ministers in London on Monday (6 November), said support for agricultural priorities in Scotland is being put at risk.

Mr Ewing said this was due to the UK Government’s “continued failure to provide certainty over the future of EU funding”.

The SNP government and UK government are clashing against the background of claims of a post-Brexit "power grab" of agricultural powers by Westminster.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon recently wrote to Prime Minister Theresa May seeking "urgent clarity" on plans for transitional arrangements.

However, First Secretary of State Damian Green has warned that farm "subsidy wars" between the devolved nations of the UK would be "counterproductive" and said there should be a single market across the UK.

No 'real progress'

Mr Ewing said that despite positive talks with ministers, the UK Government has "failed to enable real progress" to be made on the approach agreed by the Joint Ministerial Committee.

He said: “Worse, UK Defra ministers tried to amend that process which they know full well has the highest support of all our governments.

“The Scottish Government remains steadfast in its resolve to defend the devolution settlement. We will not sign a blank cheque that expects us to sign up to potential post-Brexit frameworks and legislation without knowing any of the detail of those.

“We will not put the future of our agriculture, fishing and environment sectors at risk. For 18 months we have sought to engage openly and constructively with the UK Government over some of the most important issues facing our rural economy and natural environment.

“UK ministers have yet to provide absolute clarity on future funding which prevents us and the sectors to plan for the future, nor have they given us sight of their proposed bills on agriculture and fisheries.

“Until the power grab is removed from the EU Withdrawal Bill, we can continue to have cordial discussions but little progress will be made.”

UK approach

A UK Government spokeswoman said: “We want to make sure decisions which should be taken in Scotland are taken in Scotland, as in Northern Ireland and Wales, but in some areas there will be a need for a UK approach to protect the integrity of the UK single market and not put up new barriers to trade.

“Across England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, we have a shared interest in protecting our environment and delivering a Green Brexit.”

The SNP's opinion comes in stark contrast with the farming union NFU Scotland, who agree that funding must receive a "fair allocation" across the UK, and that a UK-wide financial framework is the best option.

A think-tank has also claimed that a "core UK policy" is the best way forward when deciding how to deliver farm subsidies post-Brexit.